marrus ([info]marrus) wrote,

Facebook Intervention Day!

So, I did a FaceBook experiment yesterday. I didn’t go on the site. Not once. All day. And this was trickier than it sounds. Here’s why.

I work for myself. I’m a painter, and I wrote a book a few years ago. I wouldn’t be able to do what I do, at least not so elegantly, if it were not for the sacred boon of social networking. I have a fan page on FaceBook. Folks can choose to follow me, or not. My LiveJournal blog forwards to FaceBook, which in turn forwards to Twitter. People I’ve met, or painted (I paint skin at various festivals around the country, too), or who collect my art, or who learn about me from friends of friends – all of them can come to the Marrus-clearing house to see what I’m up to, or what I’ve created lately. They jump on the page, or jump off when they’re ready.

I try my damnedest to interact with as many as I can. I’m grateful that folks care enough about my work to follow me.

But I’ve realized what a timesuck it is. I get caught up in multiple conversations about politics, or some new movie, or a young adult novel which doesn’t pull punches, or, or, or…and all these things are detracting from my own work. But, I’ve noticed something more frightening, more insidious than just that.

Social networking is changing the way the human brain operates, or at least, MY human brain. Maybe you have a similar experience.

I think this “always connected” life we lead, is breaking our heads. I dunno about you, but I can’t focus on a task for longer than fifteen minutes before I get twitchy. I sit down to write, to paint, and the happy hours where I’d just lose myself don’t happen anymore. Now, I need the tv on, or music, or a chat window open, or to see if I’ve got email, or maybe somebody responded to my last blog post.

I don’t think it’s healthy, this pigeon-head-bobbing attention span. I kid myself that it’s necessary, I’m running multiple businesses, I need to be connected, but the cyberworld does not need me constantly massaging it.

Sure, it’s gratifying, throwing a thought out to the void, seeing who picks up on it, seeing where it goes. I’ve recently learned about “legend maintenance” in this age of short attention span theatre, we must constantly remind our audiences we’re still out here. Our hydras demand to be fed, but at what cost?

I propose a challenge. For one day, let’s make it June 30th, let’s let go of FaceBook. Realize how often our fingers reach out for the mental stimulation comprised of someone else’s lunch, or sports gossip, or baby pictures, or cute kitty videos. Wonder, without the mind-numbing pabulum of scrolling through other strangers’ lives, how better our time might be spent on our own. The human capacity for willful distraction is immense – let’s reclaim our time, our lives, the relationships right in front of us.

Here’s how hard it was for me: I had a doctor’s appointment at 8:45 am. I rode the several miles on my bike, getting to the hospital at 8:40, only to be informed that I was 23 hours and 55 minutes late, but if I wanted to wait til 9:30, perhaps the person in that time slot might not show up.

So, I waited. The TV was on, tuned loudly to a strident morning show host who kept singing snippets of showtunes, poorly. The people around me coughed and dropped things and did what strangers do when forced to wait in a small room together. My fingers twitched to check in on my phone with the folks I CARED about, but no. I got a few magazines and read them until it became clear that I’d have to come back Friday.

I headed to the gym. The elliptical trainer is boring at best, but I split my cardio time between music, the TV, and hopping online. It makes it go faster. Mebbe someone will post a cool new video that will become part of my workout mix. I fought the urge, but I fought it.

Finishing my workout, I had an appointment at one, but I was starving. I headed to my favorite restaurant for lunch. I called a friend to join me, but he was out of town, so I ate alone. Great time to look online, see what folks are doing, have a virtual lunch with someone rather than a realtime one alone. I resisted. It was hard. Instead, I focused on the fabulous food, the texture of the walls, the happy conversations around me.

Off to my next appointment. I was a half an hour early. The pull of the net was strong. I had conversations with the people around me instead.

I have a heavy smoker friend who calls her cigarettes “20 friends in a box”. With the advent of these social networking sites, we now have 200, 2000, 2,000,000 “friends”. So many distractions. No time to be quiet in our own heads, no time to work out our own conclusions, no time to just be ourselves.
Downtime is not evil. A little boredom lets us regroup. Some of my best ideas come to me when I’m in a lull. Since all this online madness started, I’ve noticed my attention span changing. Someone’s WRONG online, I drop what I’m doing. Micheal & Sarah are now friends? GREAT, that’s two seconds of my life I’ll never get back. The phone is ringing, it could be a job, or someone calling to invite me out, or a wrong number. An email shows up..a text dings…it’s the world outside our own sacred selves clamoring for attention. As for me, my thinking is getting fractured, I fall asleep with a thousand ideas of other people clamoring for attention. I’m guilty over a “friend request” of someone I genuinely like hovering in the void, but I don’t have room for even one more new voice in my head. There are already too, too many.

We must step back. We must say “no” to all these distractions so we can say a better “yes” to the things that really matter. Our own lives. Our own thoughts. Our own children, plans, creations, and yes, even a bit of boredom.

So, June 30th. Who wants to join me? We are not 140 character tweets. Those 4300 people are not your friends. "I ate a pastrami sandwich" and "My father died today" should not scroll by with the same level of gravitas.

Let’s take back our time. Let's remember what friendship truly is. Let's call this phenomenon what it is: an addiction.

Who's with me?

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 40 comments

[info]dancer

June 16 2011, 15:10:15 UTC 11 months ago

Gorgeous (and well timed)! Thank you for posting. :)

[info]marrus

June 16 2011, 15:11:27 UTC 11 months ago

Thanks for reading:)

[info]athenalove

June 16 2011, 16:00:50 UTC 11 months ago

I'm so with you! I started back when lj was brand new (1999 or so) and it boomed from there! Every word you said is true. I already have ADHD and the second I got a "smart" phone, I became "dumb" No one actually hangs out with one another, why do that when you can just scroll through you news feed? Rarley anyone uses lj any more (which at least doesn't have a limit to the words you can type and is for actual thoughts). It's crazy!

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:27:13 UTC 11 months ago

I know. 140 characters or less RULES. It's breaking my heart, and, I'm convinced, completely fucking up the way we operate & the way our kids think.

[info]vconaway

June 16 2011, 16:19:57 UTC 11 months ago

I'll pass. I think I use FB differently from most; I never, literally *never*, read my news feed. I look up individuals' pages as I'm thinking of them, which is how I ran across your post. It just happens that this morning I looked you up on FB before I got to my highly filtered friends page on LJ.

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:28:17 UTC 11 months ago

Well, we know you're a rarified creature;) Still, if you have tribe for whom this would be useful, please send out out in the world? I think it's really, REALLY important.

[info]ajnews

June 16 2011, 17:31:51 UTC 11 months ago

God, you hit on it. Finding the balance between not letting it distract, and thinking 'OMG I must promote, they gonna forget me!' I'm in.

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:28:31 UTC 11 months ago

Right? It's terrifying.

[info]mhaithaca

June 16 2011, 17:36:02 UTC 11 months ago

I'm in! It will definitely be odd for me, but I think it's a worthwhile experiment. I know I can do without Facebook, because I've done it while overseas and offline, but I like the idea of trying to do it while otherwise fully connected to the world while at work.

I'll turn off my Facebook notifications on my iPhone, so it can't interrupt me with comments, messages, etc. Any messages will show up in my e-mail, anyway. I might also refrain from opening any Twitter clients for the day.

In other news, Mel ([info]dansr) says hi. She'll be at LARF this fall! Also, I have instructions to give you a hug from her when I see you in Atlanta.

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:29:25 UTC 11 months ago

Mel KNOWS I'm not a hugger. Then again, you've perhaps earned an exception;)

Please send this out as widely as you can. I think it's hella important. Yeah. Hella. I said it;)

[info]merchimerch

June 16 2011, 17:39:21 UTC 11 months ago

This sounds great -- I'm in. My Bosnian and I try to have a screen curfew every night around 10 or 10:30, so that we spend time talking to each other, instead of buried in screens. It's worked quite well for us.

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:29:52 UTC 11 months ago

Thank you:)

[info]mahpiya_luta

June 16 2011, 18:30:25 UTC 11 months ago

Facebook is just not that big a part of my life. I can go days or even weeks without getting on. I do block game requests because I just do not have time, nor do I care, to play Farmville and Vampire whatever ad nauseum. I spend more time here checking on my friends -- of which I don't even have a dozen -- but I've been known to not even get on LJ for several days. I, like you, started realizing what a time-suck it is. Oh, I'll just check my email real fast. Wait, what was that headline? Hmm, I should look up more about that. Interesting. OK, check the email. Look, a video. Click. Look, related videos. Click. Click. Click.

Now two hours have passed, and I haven't gotten anything done.

Speaking of not getting anything done . . . . *grin* See ya. Wait, no I won't.

[info]rtred

June 16 2011, 19:56:51 UTC 11 months ago

I truly enjoy the friends and social interactions I have on Facebook and don't look at the time spent "hangin' with my peeps" there as at all wasteful. Perhaps I'd think differently if I was using it in a business sense and didn't feel as if I could simply drop people who make overly frequent or annoying posts.

As someone who telecommutes for his his job I really appreciate that I have virtual people around all day with whom I can casually interact. Count me as one of those who enjoys and appreciates just what a marvel of social engineering Facebook is.

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:32:38 UTC 11 months ago

I never said that I didn't enjoy the interaction, or that FB wasn't a marvel of social engineering.

I DID say that it's become a go-to time filler for so, so many people, myself included, and I think it's dangerous, and changing the way we think.

It seems that every time you interact with me, you aim to negate everything I'm saying. If you disagree with me so often, why do you follow me?

[info]rtred

11 months ago

[info]marrus

11 months ago

[info]rtred

11 months ago

[info]tragicwhore

June 16 2011, 20:29:45 UTC 11 months ago

I'm in. and on an unrelated note, I have a picture for you from back in the day.

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:32:59 UTC 11 months ago

Cool. And, back in the day?? You weren't born when I was back in the day!

[info]tragicwhore

11 months ago

[info]dragonmakr

June 16 2011, 22:52:29 UTC 11 months ago

I'd happily be in if I had an account. Technically I do, my bf set it up so that he could "be in a relationship" with me.

It's not just Facebook. It's so easy to go clicking around on the web for any and everything, and SUCH a time sink. I'm a slow reader (never learned how to skim!), I can sit down to hunt for some subject or product and look up and three hours have passed. And never mind how much time I waste at the office reading what passes for actual news these days.

There are business things I should be doing on the web - should have an Etsy page at the very least - but it all takes so much time, and I don't have much of it any more.

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:33:39 UTC 11 months ago

Bingo:) And, your BF? is there a new / other one?

[info]dragonmakr

11 months ago

[info]frost_faerie

June 17 2011, 00:20:52 UTC 11 months ago

You and I have had this conversation multiple times, so you know I am in total agreement with you. While I don't use FB, believing it is the Evil Empire on a personal level, I will happily abstain from all electronic forms of communication on the 30th with the exception of work email.

It's not just all the fracturing attention spans and web-addictions, either. It's the ever-increasing withdrawal from personal "real life" communication in favor of faceless electronic versions. I truly believe that by becoming more easily connected virtually, we're becoming less & less connected personally. Maybe it's becoming a smaller world, but we're not getting any closer to each other because of it.

[info]marrus

June 17 2011, 00:34:24 UTC 11 months ago

Spot on, Ms. J. And thanks for the NOLABPAL stuff - hadn't seen it before.

[info]brickhousewench

June 17 2011, 00:46:59 UTC 11 months ago

I've given up FaceBook for Lent the past two years running. It is possible to avoid it for days, weeks at a time and not miss it.

And last fall, when Jimmy Kimmel declared November 17th to be National Unfriend Day (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/11/04/national-unfriend-day-jim_n_778742.html) I took the opportunity to trim my friends list down to a more managable list. Friends aren't like Pokemon. Since I'm not running a business, I don't need to collect them all.

If you want to manage Facebook, instead of having it manage you, it is possible.

[info]rosetiger

June 17 2011, 01:02:26 UTC 11 months ago

Insightful and right on the dot, as usual.

[info]captain_snarky

June 17 2011, 04:27:28 UTC 11 months ago

I'm the only one of my friends who has no Facebook, no smartphone, and spends only about an hour, hour and a half average on the computer.
I don't "follow" anyone. I don't "tweet". When I'm alone, I read, make stuff, knit. I had IM for a week or two. Deleted it.
Someone wants to talk to me, they can pick up a phone or write me an email.
The only concession I make to the social networking thing is LJ. And the only reason I do that is because it's kind of like writing a letter to a bunch of people at once. So, more like a conversation.

I never understood what all the hoohah was about anyway. You need to focus on people to know them. You flit about the way these things do and you never know anyone. So I have a zillion minute details about someone's day. That tells me nothing about them. People don't focus on each other to begin with. Too busy focusing on themselves. Now you gonna throw Twitter at the short attention span monkey?

Welcome to the bandwagon. I've made tea.

[info]frost_faerie

June 23 2011, 23:57:23 UTC 10 months ago

I want tea!

I have no FB and no cell phone, aside from a pre-paid phone that I put $25 on every 3 months to keep the plan active. This gets used in case of emergencies only & isn't even turned on otherwise.

Some day you & I will be in the same state at the same time & there will be knitting & books & booze & no fucking FaceBook.

[info]frost_faerie

10 months ago

[info]pyroguysr

June 19 2011, 04:16:00 UTC 11 months ago

I'm with ya... but I found in the past that it takes more than just one day... it takes a minimum of 3 to 7 days to get over that twitch. Had to go camping for a week to do it.

[info]scribbledaway

June 20 2011, 13:41:07 UTC 11 months ago

Just before I logged into facebook I was thinking about this. I was wondering what it would be like to not have the laptop and internet at my beck and call constantly, and about how instantly connected we all are now. It was because of commercial that came on tv....a dad who comes home and sees his entire family each isolated in their own electronic space, pulls the power and grills some hotdogs. "Dad, what happened?!" "Power went out. Want a hotdog?"

I've taken some kind of step in reducing my continual connectedness in getting rid of my cell phone. Oh, it wasn't voluntary. My kids ran me up a huge bill and when I said "Pay it or I'm letting them shut it off" they laughed. So...I let it be shut off. I was going to instantly get another one, but my budget hasn't allowed it. And every week, now, I think "Cell phone?" and each week the temptation is less.
I LIKE not being instantly attainable and available!
I LIKE that when I'm walking the dog, or walking to work, or sitting by the river, or hanging out in the square with friend, nobody who is not with me can summon me! I LOVE not ever having to answer the indignant fussing from people who called my cell and were frustrated because I didn't instantly answer, or didn't answer at all. It's so nice not to have to ever have this conversation" "Why you didn't answer your phone?! I've been calling for hours!" "Oh, really? *check phone* Oh yeah, hm. I didn't hear it. Sorry." "Well you need to turn it up!" And then I would start feeling resentful.
Why? Why do I need to be instantly available? What if I'm doing something? What if I'm ALREADY TALKING TO SOMEONE WHO'S IN FRONT OF ME? What if I don't feel like talking on the phone?
When I got an ipod it got worse, because sometimes I wouldn't hear the phone because I was listening to music. Now I have a whole new thing to present my defense of. Why do I have my music so loud I can't hear the phone?
Why, by god, was I not instantly available when whoever it was decided they wanted to talk to me and demanded my attention?

Now....the only time people can reach me by phone is if they call my landline and I happen to be home. I have no cell phone, no answering machine, no voice mail. If I'm not home when they call then they have to call back! And, since I don't always feel like talking on the phone, I don't have to answer and they have no way of knowing that I'm home and ignoring the phone, so there are no indignant fussing attacks.

Just the way it was for most of my life, before cell phones, answering machines and voice mail were available to the general public.

AND...without the phone there is no temptation to check facebook, check my mail, check google......

I like it. It's good.

[info]nisaa

June 20 2011, 15:08:59 UTC 11 months ago

I took a Facebook holiday yesterday to avoid the Father's Day stuff. I think 24 hours is enough to get over the twitch to check it. I'm stealing your friend's idea who proposed a meetup in New Orleans. I want to see if folks want to meet up in Alameda, CA around 7 for drinks at my local tiki lounge, Forbidden Island.

[info]nisaa

July 1 2011, 06:42:03 UTC 10 months ago

I have to say that the weirdest thing about today is that I've accidentally clicked on links from people's blogs that went to facebook. And I was like "NOOOOOOO!" And I closed the window very quickly and went somewhere else.

So, there's about a half hour left to June 30th where I live. I haven't missed facebook. I think it's funny that your Facebook Intervention Day happened on the same day that I got an invitation to Google +, so yes, I explored that a bit today. Yes, I looked at twitter. But I haven't felt pulled in by the great time suck that facebook is. Do you think twitter and google + are basically the same thing as facebook? Have I failed for the day? I don't think so.

On the last facebook vacation I took, I started using a Reader for all the sites I like to read. I got back to reading things that are more than a few lines long and I prefer it. The twitch to constantly check stuff went away pretty quickly. I don't care about most of the stuff my friends from high school and college friends do all day long.

Tonight, I went out with a friend and had a drink and didn't check my phone for status updates or feel compelled to make a post about how much fun I had with her. We were both there. We had fun. No one needs to know what kind of beer I had.

Thanks and I hope you challenge people with more of these Facebook Intervention Days in the future!

[info]marrus

July 1 2011, 16:16:32 UTC 10 months ago

Thanks for letting me know, 'nise. My hope was that people would unplug entirely, no Twitter, no Google+...

I was just using FB as a scapegoat cuz it seems to be the "go-to" for folks to drop out of real human interaction under the guise of "staying connected".

[info]nisaa

10 months ago

Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…